Denied Claims

Your Roof Claim Was Denied. Now What?

A denial is one person’s position after one visit, not a verdict. What reverses them, what the law gives you, and where to go if it does not.

Free Roof Inspection Call (920) 285-0877

The Situation

Roof Insurance Claim Denied In Wisconsin? What To Do Next

A roof insurance claim denied in Wisconsin is usually reversed by documentation, not argument: get the denial in writing, read which slopes were walked, get an independent inspection with marked photographs, request a re-inspection with your contractor present, escalate inside the insurer, then the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance — free.

Adjusters look at a great many roofs in a week, usually after a regional storm when the line is long. Hail bruising is genuinely easy to miss on a weathered roof, and a slope that was not walked is a slope that was not inspected. A denial often reflects what one person saw from a ladder on one afternoon.

Why Claims Fail

The Common Denial Reasons, Explained: Wear, Wind Or Hail

“Wear and tear”

Granule loss spread evenly across a slope with the shingles brittle throughout. No policy covers it. Hail is a pattern of soft, circular impact marks with fractured mat beneath, densest on the slopes that faced the storm — a roof can be old and have been hit, and photographs with a coin for scale separate the two.

“Mechanical damage” or “installation defect”

Marks blamed on foot traffic, a satellite installer or the original nailing. Sometimes true. The answer is the pattern: hail does not stop at the slope somebody walked on, and it dents the gutters and vents as well as the shingles.

Late notice

The claim was reported outside the policy’s window. Insurers generally have to show the delay actually prejudiced their investigation, but it is an argument you do not want to be having — the deadline page explains both clocks.

Pre-existing or unrepaired damage

Damage from an earlier storm that was documented and never fixed. This is the strongest reason not to leave a known problem on file, and the reason a dated inspection report after every large storm is worth having even when nothing is claimed.

Six Steps

What To Do After A Roof Claim Denial, In Order

Get the denial in writing

Ask for the reason and the policy language it relies on. A verbal “no storm damage” is not something you can respond to; a letter citing an exclusion is.

Read the adjuster’s report

You are entitled to it. Check which slopes were walked — often not all — and whether the damage was called wear, mechanical, or manufacturing defect. Each is answered differently.

Get an independent inspection

Photographs of marked, measured damage on every slope, dated, with the granule loss and exposed mat visible. This is the evidence the file is missing, and it is free.

Request a re-inspection with better documentation

Ask specifically for a re-inspection with your contractor present. Insurers grant it routinely, and your contractor may discuss the damage with the adjuster on the roof — how that meeting goes.

Escalate inside the insurer

A supervisor or a different adjuster. Every carrier has an internal review before anything formal, and a well-documented re-inspection request usually ends there.

Then the regulator

The Office of the Commissioner of Insurance takes complaints about claim handling from Wisconsin consumers, free, at 1-800-236-8517. That is the step before a public adjuster or a lawyer.

What the law says

Wisconsin’s three-business-day contract cancellation right after a denial

You may cancel this contract at any time before midnight on the third business day after you have received written notice from your insurer that the claim has been denied in whole or in part under the property insurance policy.
Wis. Stat. § 100.65(3)(a) — the notice a roofing contract must carry

Wisconsin requires every residential roofing contract tied to an insurance claim to carry this notice in bold type, with a detachable cancellation form. Cancel in writing within three business days of the denial letter and, under subsection (6), the contractor must return your payments within ten days — less only the reasonable value of emergency work you acknowledged in writing. If your contract does not carry the notice, that is a separate problem with the contractor, not with your right.

Escalating

When A Public Adjuster Or A Lawyer Is The Right Call

After the re-inspection and the internal review have failed and the amount in dispute justifies the cost — a public adjuster is licensed by the state, works for you, and is paid a percentage of the settlement; a lawyer works by the hour or on contingency. Before either, file with the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance: it is free, the insurer must answer it, and it resolves a surprising share of disputes on its own.

We are neither an adjuster nor a lawyer and will say so when you need one. What we provide is the inspection, the photographs, a contractor’s estimate, and a presence on the roof when the adjuster comes back; if the denial stands after all of that, we will tell you so rather than encourage a fight you cannot win.

What the law says

Once a claim is agreed, payment has a deadline too

Unless otherwise provided by law, an insurer shall promptly pay every insurance claim. A claim shall be overdue if not paid within 30 days after the insurer is furnished written notice of the fact of a covered loss and of the amount of the loss. … All overdue payments shall bear simple interest at the rate of 7.5 percent per year.
Wis. Stat. § 628.46(1)

The thirty days run from written notice of the loss and its amount — in practice, from proof of loss. An insurer with reasonable proof that it is not liable is not overdue, which is why a denial is different from a delay. But an agreed scope that sits unpaid for six weeks is accruing interest at 7.5 percent, and saying so politely tends to move it.

Straight Answers

Denial Questions

Sometimes, and the distinction is physical rather than rhetorical. Wear is granule loss spread evenly across a slope with the shingles brittle throughout; no policy covers it. Hail bruising is a pattern of soft, circular impact marks with fractured mat beneath, densest on the slopes that faced the storm, often with matching dents on the metal vents and gutters. What hail does to a shingle has the photographs.

No — Wis. Stat. § 100.65(8) prohibits a contractor from representing or negotiating for you. We provide the inspection, the photographs, a contractor’s estimate, and we will be on the roof when the adjuster comes back. The conversation with the insurer stays yours, and if it stalls, the regulator is a phone call.

Two clocks. Your policy sets the time to report and to submit proof of loss, and those are contract terms — read Duties After Loss. The statute sets the deadline to bring an action: Wis. Stat. § 631.83(1)(a), twelve months from the date the loss occurred, which a policy may not shorten, and which is paused while an appraisal or arbitration under the policy is under way. Do not let a dispute drift toward it.

Nothing from us. We do not charge to attend a re-inspection or to prepare the photographs and estimate for one, and the report is yours whether or not the roof is ever ours to replace. The free inspection is the same visit, with the adjuster’s report in hand.

Insurance claims

The hub: what a contractor may and may not do in a claim, the sequence, and the six pages that go deeper.

All claims pages

The questions we get asked

Cost, timing, permits, insurance and warranties, answered plainly on one page.

Roofing FAQ

The deadline

Twelve months from the storm to bring an action under § 631.83, and the shorter clock in your policy. Do not let a dispute drift toward it.

Claim deadlines

Hail damage repair

What hail bruising looks like on a roof and how it differs from wear — the distinction most denials turn on.

Hail damage

This page explains how Wisconsin law and a typical homeowner policy treat a roof claim. It is general information, not legal advice, and your own policy is the document that governs your claim. Where we quote a statute we link it so you can read it yourself.

Second Opinion

Had A Claim Denied?

Send us the adjuster’s report. We will walk the roof, photograph what is there, and tell you honestly whether the denial looks right.

Call (920) 285-0877 Request an Inspection